Podcast Episode: Sermon: Proper 27 RCL A1 – “Stepping Out of the Circle”

Pip: A Roman ambassador draws a circle in the sand around one of the most powerful rulers in the ancient world and says, essentially, decide now. That's the image Fr. John brings to a sermon about grace, free will, and what it means to choose God — and it lands.

Mara: This episode covers that sermon and the theology it unpacks — prevenient grace, sustaining grace, the parable of the ten virgins, and what Joshua's ancient challenge still asks of us today. Let's start with the circle.

Stepping Out of the Circle: Grace, Choice, and What Comes Next

Pip: The sermon opens with a deceptively simple question: when God invites you to choose, what kind of choice is it really — compelled obedience, or something else entirely?

Mara: The contrast is set up through that Roman ambassador and Antiochus, but then the sermon draws the line clearly: "One decision was compelled by fear of an empire. The other was made possible by the grace God had already poured out upon His people and would continue to do so."

Pip: So the circle isn't a threat. That reframe is the whole sermon in miniature — the stakes are real, but the posture is invitation, not ultimatum.

Mara: And the theological term for what makes that invitation possible is prevenient grace — God acting before we respond. The sermon quotes First John directly: "We love because God first loved us." That's the engine. Before we reach for God, God has already reached for us.

Pip: Which is where St. Francis de Sales comes in, with a parable that does a lot of quiet heavy lifting.

Mara: A king and his bride — she collapses, he revives her, helps her walk, places a healing salve on her heart. And then the line that stays with you: "But the king never let go of her hand." That's sustaining grace. Not a one-time rescue, but ongoing accompaniment.

Pip: Though free will is still in the room. The bride can pull her hand away. The sermon is honest about that — love cannot be forced — and that's not a loophole, it's the point.

Mara: The ten virgins parable carries the same warning. All ten responded to the invitation initially. Only five stayed prepared. The sermon frames it as a question worth sitting with: "We may have chosen God long ago, but are we still cooperating with the grace that enables us to remain faithful today?"

Pip: Sartre said we are our choices. The sermon borrows that and turns it pastoral — where have your choices led you, and is God still in the picture?

Mara: And the answer offered isn't condemnation. It's Isaiah 41:13: "I, the Lord your God, hold your right hand; it is I who say to you, Fear not, I am the one who helps you." The hand is still extended.


Pip: A circle drawn in sand, a king who never lets go — the images stay because they're doing real theological work, not just decoration.

Mara: Grace that precedes us, sustains us, and waits for us when we wander. That's the territory. We'll keep following it.

Podcast Episode: Sermon: All Saints Day RCL A – “Shining Like the Sun”

Pip: There's a sermon on Candle in a Cave this week that opens with Elizabeth Gilbert, winds through Oliver Cromwell melting down saints for loose change, and lands on Thomas Merton standing on a Louisville street corner having a revelation. As cold opens go, the sermon itself has a pretty good one.

Mara: Fr. John's writing this week centers on what sainthood actually means — who the saints were as people, and what that humanness is supposed to tell us about ourselves. Let's start with that question of saints, pedestals, and what we're missing when we put people too high up on them.

Saints, Sinners, and the Pedestals We Build

Pip: The sermon sets up a tension that's easy to miss: we honor the saints, but the way we honor them might be the thing that makes them useless to us. If they're flawless icons, they can't actually show us anything about how to live.

Mara: The post draws on Thomas Merton to make this concrete. After a moment of unexpected clarity walking through Louisville in 1958, Merton wrote in Conjectures of a Guilty Bystander: "I have the immense joy of being man, a member of a race in which God Himself became incarnate. As if the sorrows and stupidities of the human condition could overwhelm me, now that I realize what we all are. And if only everybody could realize this! But it cannot be explained. There is no way of telling people that they are all walking around shining like the sun."

Pip: So the upshot is: the monk who spent years treating religious life as separate from ordinary humanity looked at strangers on a street corner and saw something luminous in them. That's not a small pivot.

Mara: And the sermon grounds that in the saints' own testimony. St. Francis de Sales is remembered for gentleness, but had a wicked temper. St. Thérèse of Lisieux admits to getting irritated by a fellow sister's strange noises. St. Teresa of Avila writes in her autobiography's preface, "My life has been so wretched that I have not found a saint among those who were converted to God in whom I can find comfort."

Pip: Saints, essentially, filing complaints about their own canonization.

Mara: The point the sermon makes is that their humanness is the encouraging part — not the obstacle. If holiness was attainable for people with real flaws and real struggles, it remains attainable. The sermon puts it directly: "Their humanness tells us that such a life, such a soul, such faith — even in all its brokenness and sinfulness — is attainable, if we are willing, through God's grace, to reach for it."

Mara: And then the practical frame: if you want to be a good writer, you write. If you want to be good at sports, you do the work. Holiness, the sermon argues, runs on the same logic — practice, consistency, cooperation with grace.

Pip: Merton never made official sainthood — the sermon is candid about that, listing his beer, his girlfriend, his talent for irritating people. But he's described as one of the most influential religious figures of the twentieth century. The argument is that the category matters less than the direction of travel.

Mara: Which circles back to the 1 John reading underneath the whole sermon: "We are God's children now." Not eventually. The grace is available in the present tense, and the invitation is to live as though that's actually true.

Pip: The Cromwell anecdote is worth a mention — when England faced a silver shortage, his committee found silver only in cathedral statues of saints. Cromwell's solution: melt them down and put them into circulation. The sermon uses it to bracket both extremes, abolishing the saints entirely on one end, uncritical veneration on the other.

Mara: And the closing image pulls everything together — if we could see one another the way Merton saw those strangers in Louisville, we might find something the sermon calls wonderful. "We are all walking around shining like the sun."


Pip: The through-line this week is a pretty old question dressed in new examples — what do we actually see when we look at each other?

Mara: Merton's answer was that the seeing itself changes when you stop insisting on separateness. Worth sitting with until next time.

Podcast Episode: Sermon: Proper 21 RCL A1 – “Massah and Meribah”

Pip: There's a sermon on this week's feed that opens with a joke about Joan of Arc — and somehow lands in the middle of the Sinai desert without losing anyone. Fr. John has been busy.

Mara: This episode covers one sermon — but it moves through a lot of territory: wilderness thirst, reasonable expectations, a parable about a vineyard, and what the Church is actually for. Let's start with the desert.

Sermon: Proper 21 RCL A1 — Massah and Meribah

Pip: The sermon opens with a question the Israelites asked at Rephidim — "Is the Lord among us or not?" — and it's framed not as ancient faithlessness but as something recognizable. The tension is between reasonable expectation and a wasteland where nothing arrives.

Mara: The setup matters here. The Israelites weren't wandering blindly — they were traveling oasis to oasis, as commanded. The sermon notes, "The whole congregation of the Israelites journeyed by stages, as the Lord commanded." They did what they were told, and they arrived somewhere dry.

Pip: Which is the real sting of the story. This wasn't recklessness punished — it was faithfulness that hit a wall. You followed the route, and the oasis was empty.

Mara: And the sermon is careful not to let the congregation feel superior to the Israelites. It points out that these are the same people who witnessed the ten plagues, the parting of the sea, the cloud by day and fire by night — and roughly forty-five days later, they're questioning whether God is present at all. The place gets renamed: Massah and Meribah, testing and quarreling.

Pip: Right — and the sermon doesn't leave it as a cautionary tale about ancient ingratitude. It pivots to something harder.

Mara: Much harder. It asks whether each listener has a place in their own life that started as Rephidim — a legitimate destination — and became Massah and Meribah. The sermon lists it plainly: "The prayer isn't answered, the relationship cracks, the sickness persists… there is no water."

Pip: That's where the parable of the two sons comes in, and it's doing more work than it might seem.

Mara: The sermon focuses on the first son — the one who says no and then goes anyway. Nothing changes externally; there's still no water. What changes is the son. And the sermon offers two reasons he goes back: obedience, and relationship. It calls obedience "a very distant second."

Pip: The primary reason is that the son knows the father has always been faithful — so he trusts the father has reasons, even when the vineyard is brutal and the water hasn't come.

Mara: The sermon closes with something specific about what the Church can and cannot do. It doesn't promise a timeline. It says, "I can sit with you in Rephidim. When you cannot remember what God has done, I can remember it for you. When you cannot pray, I can pray for you." The community itself becomes the evidence that God is present.

Pip: Which is a quieter answer than most people want — but probably the only honest one available.


Mara: The through-line here is expectation — what we're owed, what we trust, and what we do when the oasis is dry.

Pip: Next time, bring water. Or at least someone who remembers where the last spring was.

Podcast Episode: Sermon: Feast of St. Matthew

Pip: Fire-breathing dragons, a martyrdom at the altar, and a painter who hid himself in the scene running away — Fr. John has been busy.

Mara: This episode follows a single sermon preached on the Feast of St. Matthew, tracing the saint's legend from Jerusalem to Ethiopia, and ending with a question about what it means to keep looking back at the Gospel even as we walk away from it.

Pip: Let's start with the legend itself, and what it asks of us.

Matthew, Ethiopia, and the Man Running Away

Mara: The sermon opens in apocryphal territory — not the canonical Gospels but the Acts of the Holy Apostle Thomas, where the apostles divide up the known world before scattering to evangelize it.

Pip: The verbatim passage sets the scene directly: "we the apostles were all in Jerusalem — Simon called Peter, and Andrew his brother; James the son of Zebedee, and John his brother; Philip and Bartholomew; Thomas, and Matthew the tax-gatherer… and we portioned out the regions of the world, in order that each one of us might go into the region that fell to him."

Mara: Matthew's region, according to Jacobus de Voragine's Golden Legend, is Ethiopia — where he settles with the very eunuch Philip had baptized on the road to Gaza, and spends thirty-three years converting the country.

Pip: Dragons lay down at his feet. A king's son rises from the dead. The king announces, quote, "Come and see God in the likeness of a man" — and Matthew redirects all the gold toward building a church. Quite the ministry.

Mara: The sermon doesn't stop at the legend. It moves to Caravaggio's Martyrdom of Saint Matthew in Rome, where the saint lies on the altar steps, hand raised — not to ward off the executioner's blow, but to receive a palm branch from an angel above.

Pip: And then the sermon finds its real subject: a second face in the painting. Just behind the executioner's shoulder, Caravaggio painted himself — watching the scene and walking away from it.

Mara: The sermon asks what that figure means for the rest of us. The words are plain: "We hear the Gospel. We know what Christ asks of us… And sometimes we do. But sometimes we turn away. Sometimes the demands of the Gospel are more than we want to bear."

Pip: But the man is still looking back. That's the hinge the whole sermon turns on.

Mara: Right — and the sermon holds that tension without resolving it cheaply. The question it leaves is not whether we'd have the courage to die as Matthew did, but whether we have the courage to turn around while we're still alive.

Pip: The palm branch is waiting. The painting says the journey isn't over yet.


Mara: A saint's legend, a Caravaggio self-portrait, and a question about where we place ourselves in the scene.

Pip: Still looking back. Which, apparently, is where grace begins.

Podcast Episode: Sermon: Proper 19 RCL A1 – “What are You Building?”

Pip: Star Wars, Pharaoh, a donkey with delusions of grandeur — Fr. John is covering a lot of ground this week at Candle in a Cave.

Mara: The sermon for Proper 19 pulls together the Exodus story, the parable of the unforgiving servant, and a question that runs through all of it: what are you actually building with what God has given you?

Pip: Let's get into it.

"What Are You Building?" — Gifts, Empires, and the Kingdom

Mara: The sermon opens with a sweep through history — every great empire, from the British to the Mongol to the Babylonian, eventually collapses. That pattern sets up the Exodus reading, where Pharaoh insists the Nile is his own making.

Pip: And the sermon lands the line that becomes the sermon's spine. After the Israelites cross the Red Sea and receive Egyptian gold as a parting gift from God, they melt it into a golden calf — and the sermon reads that act as Pharaoh's logic recycled: "My Nile is my own; I made it for myself."

Mara: That phrase does the heavy lifting. The Israelites were liberated, given a gift, and then used the gift to rebuild the very thing they escaped — their own version of Egypt, their own small empire.

Pip: Which is where the parable of the unforgiving servant walks in and makes the same point at human scale. The king forgives an impossible debt — the sea parts, the servant walks through free — and then the servant immediately shakes down a colleague for pocket change.

Mara: The sermon draws the parallel directly: "The servant took the gift of mercy and, in his arrogance, began building his own little empire." Liberation received, liberation refused to others.

Pip: And then there is the donkey. Decorated with garlands to carry a sacred icon, he stops mid-procession and brays at the crowd, convinced the adoration is for him. The man leading him swats him and says, "The honor is not meant for you but for the image you are carrying."

Mara: That fable lands the sermon's practical point. The gifts — wealth, education, position, talent — are not the problem. The sermon is clear: "The gold was never the problem. Possessing the gold was never the problem. The question was what they built with it."

Pip: Wealth can build an empire or serve the Kingdom. Same gold, entirely different structure.

Mara: Saint James frames it as the law of liberty — freedom from sin that teaches liberated people how to live, and Saint Peter adds: "use it to serve one another, as good stewards of God's varied grace… in order that in everything God may be glorified through Jesus Christ."

Pip: Every empire falls. The sermon closes on that contrast — every empire we build eventually collapses, and God's Kingdom endures forever — and asks why anyone would choose the perishable project.

Mara: The closing prayer puts it plainly: serve without counting the cost, labor without seeking rest, spend yourself for glory that belongs to someone else entirely.


Pip: Pharaoh, a servant, and a self-important donkey — same story, different costumes.

Mara: The question underneath all of it stays simple: the gift is in your hands. What are you building with it?

Podcast Episode: Sermon: Proper 18 RCL A1 – “Reconciliation”

Pip: There's a sermon on Candle in a Cave that opens with Shakespeare, detours through a shrew the size of a penny, and ends with a butcher knife in a teenager's hand — and somehow it's all about forgiveness.

Mara: Fr. John's recent writing takes us into the hard territory of reconciliation — what the Gospel actually asks of us when someone genuinely wrongs us, and why the answer isn't what we'd prefer.

Pip: Let's start with the sermon itself.

What Reconciliation Actually Costs

Pip: The Gospel passage at the center of this sermon sounds, at first read, like permission — Jesus telling us to go confront the person who wronged us. The question the sermon presses on is what motivation we're actually supposed to bring to that confrontation.

Mara: The setup begins with Katherine from The Taming of the Shrew — a character whose fury is her defining feature. The sermon draws a line from her to what it calls the grouch and the shrew in all of us, and then lands here: "It's as if Jesus is giving us permission to be the grouch or the shrew we know we have every right to be."

Pip: Which is a fair read of the text — until it isn't.

Mara: Right, and that's exactly the pivot the sermon makes. The cockroach exercise is where it gets concrete. A dozen teenagers, a paper box with a cockroach image taped to the lid, and a butcher knife. They shred the cockroach completely — and underneath is an image of Jesus, also shredded. The outrage is immediate.

Pip: Probably not the pastoral risk assessment form they teach in seminary, but the lesson lands.

Mara: The sermon draws the theological line directly from that image: "Whatever you do to them, you do to Jesus." And it holds that against the Gospel's one sentence that's easy to skip past.

Mara: That sentence is: "If the member listens to you, you have regained that one." The sermon reads that as the whole point — the motivation isn't vengeance, it's reconciliation. Paul's letter to the Romans backs it up: "Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God, for it is written, 'Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord.'"

Pip: So the upshot is that the passage isn't a license to build a team and stock up on ammunition — it's a call to want the other person back.

Mara: And the sermon is careful about what reconciliation doesn't require. It doesn't mean forgetting, pretending you weren't hurt, or allowing the offender back into your life. What it does mean, as the sermon puts it, is you release the desire to go stab cockroaches — you refuse to let someone else's sin dictate who you become.

Pip: The closing image is the early martyrs who had no great words, just a simple reply when told to renounce their faith or die.

Mara: "I am a Christian." The sermon offers that as the thing to say to yourself in the moment anger tips toward vengeance — not a denial of the harm, but a refusal to be ruled by it.

Pip: And the final line reframes the familiar "where two or three are gathered" — not a formula for a small meeting, but a description of a reconciled community.


Mara: The through-line here is that reconciliation is the shape of Jesus' entire ministry — and the sermon asks whether we're willing to let that be the shape of ours.

Pip: Even when the cockroach really had it coming. More from Candle in a Cave next time.

Podcast Episode: Sermon: Proper 17 RCL A1 – “Defying the Furnace”

Pip: There's a sermon on Candle in a Cave that opens with a medical transcription disaster and lands, somehow, on the fiery furnace of Daniel. Fr. John has range.

Mara: This episode follows that sermon through three interlocking figures — Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, Moses at the burning bush, and Jesus heading toward Jerusalem — all circling the same question about faith under pressure.

Pip: Let's get into the furnace.

—

Defying the Furnace: Faith That Doesn't Negotiate

Mara: The sermon sets up a central tension right away: what does faith actually look like when the outcome is genuinely uncertain — when God might save you, or might not?

Pip: And the sermon's answer comes straight from Daniel, chapter three. The setup is worth naming: three Jewish men in Nebuchadnezzar's court, condemned for refusing to worship a golden statue, standing in front of a king who asks who could possibly save them now.

Mara: The text gives their reply directly: "Our God whom we serve is able to deliver us from the burning fiery furnace, and he will deliver us out of your hand, O king. But if not, be it known to you, O king, that we will not serve your gods or worship the golden image that you have set up."

Pip: "But if not." That's the hinge. They're not bargaining with God, and they're not promising themselves a rescue. They're saying the furnace does not get to decide who they are.

Mara: Right — and the sermon makes the stakes plain: their faith was not contingent on the outcome. It was, as the text puts it, "simply in God and His divine providence, without qualification."

Pip: Which is where Moses comes in, and this is a sharp move. God tells Moses to walk back into Egypt — back into the place he fled, as a wanted man, to confront Pharaoh. God doesn't promise it will be easy. The sermon frames it plainly: "I am sending you into the furnace, and I will be with you."

Mara: That phrase — "I will be with you" — is the thread connecting all three figures. The sermon notes that God never spoke those words directly to Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego. But Nebuchadnezzar's own testimony proved them true: a fourth figure, unbound, walking in the fire beside them.

Pip: And then there's Peter, flinching when Jesus announces he's headed to Jerusalem to suffer and die. A very human reaction. The sermon doesn't mock him for it.

Mara: It doesn't. The sermon reads Jesus's rebuke as clarification, not condemnation — Jesus already knows the Father is with him, and he's telling Peter: follow me through the furnace, because I will be with you in yours.

Pip: The sermon ends with a kind of stripped-down catechism. Standing in front of the furnace, all the complicated answers fall away. What's left? "I believe in one God, the Father Almighty." Not an explanation. Not a guarantee. Just that.

Mara: The closing line lands it: "I believe does mean we are not walking into the furnace alone."

—


Pip: Faith that holds without a promised outcome — that's a harder ask than most furnace stories let on.

Mara: It is. And that question of what remains when the answers run out seems like territory worth returning to.

AI-Generated Podcast Episode: Sermon: Proper 13 RCL A – “Providence and Prayer”

Pip: A three-year-old invoking the name of Jesus to score twenty-three boxes of chocolate chip cookies — honestly, that is the most theologically efficient prayer in recorded history.

Mara: That story opens a sermon by Fr. John, and it turns out to be the perfect door into something much larger: what prayer actually does when God already has a plan.

Pip: Right — and that tension between providence and petition is exactly where this episode lives. Let's get into it.

Providence, Prayer, and a Busted Hip

Mara: The central question here is one that anyone who has prayed and waited and heard nothing will recognize: if God has a wise, loving plan already in motion, what is the point of asking?

Pip: The sermon lands its answer through Jacob — a man who wrestled God at the Jabbok River and refused to let go. Here is the line that frames everything: "Jacob prayed, 'Bless me,' and the Lord replied, 'What you are asking is good, but it is too small.'"

Mara: That reframe is the hinge of the whole argument. Jacob got his blessing — but it arrived as a dislocated hip, a new name, and a lineage that eventually produced Jesus of Nazareth. The prayer was answered; it just expanded far beyond what Jacob could have conceived.

Pip: So the sermon is not really arguing that God ignores us. It is arguing that our requests are structurally too small for what God is doing.

Mara: Exactly, and three reasons for prayer follow from that. The first two are fairly direct: Jesus commands it, and prayer enlarges the soul to receive more of God — the sermon uses the image of a teaspoon versus a five-gallon bucket both dipped in the ocean. Neither empties the ocean; one simply holds more.

Pip: The third reason is the one with some weight to it.

Mara: It is. The sermon draws on Paul's letter to the Corinthians: "We are God's fellow workers. You are God's field, God's building." The claim is that prayer is not just petition — it is participation. God wants us asking so we can be woven into the work itself.

Pip: Which reframes the unanswered prayer entirely. You are not being ignored; you are being incorporated.

Mara: And when we do not know what to ask for, Paul's words from Romans carry the load: "The Spirit himself intercedes for us with groanings too deep for words." Our feeble attempts, the sermon says, are taken and perfected.

Pip: Twenty-three boxes of cookies, or a busted hip — either way, you are not praying into a void.


Mara: The through-line is that providence and prayer are not in competition — prayer is how we become part of the story rather than just recipients of it.

Pip: Jacob limped away from that riverbank with everything he asked for and more than he bargained for. That seems about right. More next time.

Podcast Episode: Sermon: Proper 11 RCL A – “Identifying Weeds”

Pip: There is a cave, and there is a candle — and this week, someone lit it by asking who gets to decide which plants are weeds.

Mara: That question runs straight through the posts Fr. John published recently — a sermon that moves from a Charlie Brown comic strip to a Persian king to the parable of the wheat and the weeds. Let's start with the field.

Sermon: Proper 11 RCL A — Identifying Weeds

Pip: The sermon opens with a very relatable Lucy moment — she tells Charlie Brown his problem is simply that he is himself — and uses it to name something the sermon treats as a persistent human instinct: the confidence that we can correctly identify who the troublemakers are.

Mara: The sermon sets up that instinct and then runs it straight into Isaiah, where the Lord designates a deliverer for Israel. Here is the passage: "I have stirred him up in righteousness, and I will make all his ways level; he shall build my city and set my exiles free, not for price or reward, says the Lord of hosts."

Pip: And the deliverer in question is not David, not Gideon, not Jesus — it is Cyrus, a pagan king who worshipped idols and had never heard of the God of Israel. Which means the people hearing Isaiah's announcement would have looked at their liberator and seen exactly the wrong kind of person.

Mara: That is precisely the tension the sermon develops. Cyrus conquered Babylon, freed the Israelites, and funded the rebuilding of Jerusalem — all without sharing their faith. The sermon then moves to the gospel parable, where a farmer's field fills with Darnel, a poisonous grass nearly indistinguishable from wheat until the grain head forms.

Pip: By the time you can tell the difference, the roots are so tangled that pulling the weed destroys the wheat. So the farmer says: wait. Which is, frankly, a harder instruction than it sounds when you have already mentally drafted your weed-pulling list.

Mara: Augustine is quoted directly on this: "How many sheep are outside, how many wolves within! And how many sheep are inside, how many wolves without! How many are blaspheming Christ who will yet believe in Him!"

Mara: The sermon holds up Paul as the case in point — present at Stephen's stoning, feared by the early church, and yet the future Apostle to the Gentiles. The people who saw a wolf were not lying; they were simply wrong.

Pip: So the sermon's practical instruction lands in Romans 12 — repay no evil for evil, feed your enemy if he is hungry — because the alternative is letting someone else's sin generate yours.

Mara: And the sermon closes with a sharp reversal: those who crucified Jesus believed they were doing exactly the right kind of weed removal. The job of identifying and pulling, the sermon argues, belongs to the angels at the end of the age — not to us.


Pip: What stays with me is Cyrus — the idea that the person you would most confidently label a weed might be the one God has already called by name.

Mara: That tension between what we see and what God sees seems like territory worth returning to. More to come from Candle in a Cave.