Podcast Episode: Sermon: Proper 9 RCL A – “In God We Trust”

Pip: If you've ever wondered what pesto, the Cold War, and the Book of Isaiah have in common, Fr. John has done the research, and the answer is more coherent than it has any right to be.

Mara: This episode follows a single sermon that moves from the origins of a national motto to the harder question underneath it โ€” the difference between believing in God and actually trusting God. Let's start with that journey from Virgil's kitchen to the gates of Jerusalem.

Sermon: Trusting God or Just Saying So

Pip: The sermon opens with a question about national identity, but it's really asking something more uncomfortable โ€” whether "In God We Trust" is a conviction or just text printed on currency.

Mara: The setup begins in an unexpected place. Virgil, writing a pesto recipe around 50 BC, produced the phrase that became America's first de facto motto. As the sermon puts it: "out of many, a single color โ€” color est e pluribus unus โ€” and if we shorten that and add proper grammar, we have the phrase e pluribus unum, which the founding fathers added to the Great Seal of the United States in 1782."

Pip: So the founding motto was essentially a salad metaphor. And it held for over 170 years until the Cold War made atheism the enemy and "In God We Trust" became the official counter-move in 1956.

Mara: That shift sets up the sermon's real question. The motto changed, but the sermon asks whether the trust behind it changed with it. And the answer comes through Hezekiah, king of Judah around 700 BC.

Pip: Hezekiah is a useful case study because he's not a villain. He kept the religious observances, ran the temple, did the visible things โ€” and yet Isaiah records God saying, essentially, I've had enough of your burnt offerings.

Mara: The problem was that Hezekiah believed in God but didn't trust him. When Assyria threatened, he sought an alliance with Egypt instead. The sermon quotes Isaiah directly: "Woe to those who go down to Egypt for help and rely on horses, who trust in chariots because they are many โ€” but do not look to the Holy One of Israel or consult the Lord."

Pip: It took the Assyrian army standing outside Jerusalem's gates before Hezekiah actually prayed. Which is a very human timeline for getting serious about trust.

Mara: And the sermon draws that line straight to the gospel. Jesus's invitation to "take my yoke" gets read not as shared labor with a partner, but as a replacement โ€” setting down the yoke of sin, self, and fear, and picking up the yoke of discipleship instead.

Pip: The question the sermon lands on is precise: not "do you believe?" โ€” the congregation already answered that by showing up โ€” but "do you trust him enough to remove all those yokes and put on his?"

Mara: It closes with Thomas Merton's prayer, which holds the tension honestly: "I have no idea where I am going. I do not see the road ahead of me." Trust, the sermon argues, doesn't require certainty. It requires the desire to follow, and Merton's prayer suggests that desire itself is already a form of faithfulness.

Pip: In God We Trust โ€” lip service or a way of life. That's the question left sitting in the pew.


Mara: The thread running through all of this is the gap between profession and practice โ€” saying the words and living the weight of them.

Pip: Belief is the easy part, apparently. Trust is where it gets costly. We'll see what Candle in a Cave brings next time.

Podcast Episode: Sermon: Proper 8 RCL A – “Empowered Servants of God”

Pip: There's a Peanuts cartoon that opens a sermon, and somehow it leads directly to eternal life โ€” which is either a bold homiletical move or proof that Lucy van Pelt has always been theologically underrated.

Mara: This episode covers one sermon from Fr. John, working through what it means to be part of a body where every gift counts โ€” not just the ones delivered from a pulpit.

Pip: Let's start with the sermon itself, and the question of who actually does the work of the church.

Empowered for the Mission โ€” Every Gift Counts

Mara: The sermon is built around a deceptively simple question: if not everyone is called to preach or heal or cast out demons, what exactly is everyone else doing in the mission of God?

Pip: The answer comes from the tail end of Matthew 10, Jesus wrapping up his instructions to the twelve before sending them out. The setup is that hardship is guaranteed โ€” and so is help from unexpected quarters.

Mara: The sermon lands the key line directly from that passage: "Whoever receives you, receives me, and whoever receives me, receives the Father." The argument is that welcoming and supporting those who carry the mission makes you a participant in it.

Pip: Which is a genuinely generous theological claim โ€” you don't have to be the one casting out demons to get credit for the demon-casting.

Mara: Two Old Testament figures anchor that claim. Elijah and the widow of Zarephath: she shares her last flour and oil, and the jar never empties. Later, her son dies and Elijah raises him. Elisha and the Shunammite woman: she feeds him whenever he passes through, and Elisha promises her a son she had stopped hoping for.

Pip: Both women receive what the sermon calls the prophet's reward โ€” not because they prophesied, but because they made the prophet's work possible.

Mara: Paul's letter to the Corinthians supplies the structural argument: "There are varieties of gifts, but the same Spirit; and there are varieties of service, but the same Lord; and there are varieties of activities, but it is the same God who empowers them all in everyone. To each is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the common good."

Mara: The upshot is that no single gift runs the whole operation. The apostles need the widow's flour. The prophet needs the Shunammite's hospitality. The body needs every member.

Pip: And the sermon loops back to Lucy at this point โ€” those five fingers, individually nothing, curled together into something formidable. It is, against all odds, the correct analogy.

Mara: Archbishop Michael Ramsey gets the closing description of what that body looks like across centuries: "Human lives united to Jesus, receiving his presence, and showing his goodness, his love, his sacrifice, his humility and his compassion. Living stones."

Pip: The sermon closes by naming the stakes beyond the prophet's reward โ€” Christ's reward, forgiveness and resurrection, the food that does not perish. The call is direct: find where your gift fits, and get to work.

Mara: The harvest line from Luke lands as the final push: "The harvest is plentiful, but the laborers are few." Every laborer counts, regardless of what kind of laboring they do.


Pip: One sermon, but the argument keeps widening โ€” from twelve apostles to a widow's jar to every person sitting in a pew wondering if they have anything to offer.

Mara: The answer the sermon gives is yes, unambiguously. The body needs what you have. More on that territory next time.

INTERVIEW: Tornado Alley Mystery Writers

I was fortunate to have the opportunity to interview with the Tornado Alley Mystery Writers and discuss writing and life. You can listen to the interview (about thirty minutes long) on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Buzzsprout.

The book we discussed is the first in the Father Anthony Savel Mysteries series, titled The Golden Fistula. Click the image or link to view it on Amazon.

Other books available are:

I am currently working on the third Father Anthony Mystery: The Forty-Second Wife.